* Please return by:
This form is for your convenience. Conclusions can be reported by check mark, but your
comments are particularly important. Feel free to add a sheet if needed.
Date: Manuscript #:
Manuscript Submitted to Section (circle):
Feature Articles Essay Reviews & Interviews Voces Book & Media Reviews Alternative Formats
1. Recommend acceptance as is (also please check a, b or c).
a. Major contribution. b. Warrants publication. c. Acceptable to publish if space is plentiful.
2. Recommend acceptance with reservation (please specify below).
a. Not exceptionally important and/or substantial b. Other
3. May be publishable with extensive revisions and further review.
4. Recommend rejection. With extensive revisions would probably still be of
borderline quality (please check one or more of the following).
a. Topic unsuitable (suggest another journal?). b. Contributes nothing new.
c. Technically deficient (specify). d. Other
References: 1. Adequate. 2. Inadequate (add any suggestions below).
Format (APA), Style, Order and Elements, etc (if applicable, and acceptance recommended):
1. Well written, routine editing. 2. Needs considerable editing (please specify below).
Comments (for author):